World Youth Day


I think World Youth Day sucks for all kinds of reasons.
I don't think that any of the tiers of government should be financially supporting any kind of private religious celebration, and the fact that NSW Labor is speaks to the corruption, the social conservatism and the dominance of the Catholic church in that party. It's just not healthy, no matter how you care to spin it.
I also resent the fact that WYD is really just presenting one face of Catholic spirituality, and its a pretty ugly face. It's a kind of Nuremberg Rally of right-wing Catholicism, and I resent being exepected to be excited about it. Don't tell me how much money it's going to contribute to the local economy (not half as much as the Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras, which gets zilch from the government), or how wonderful it will be to have the streets filled with wholesome, Christian young people intent on doing good. I would suggest that the central message of WYD does a lot of bad to, for example, young gay and lesbian people, or young people who might happen to be Hindu or Buddhist, or young people who might want to retain the freedom and integrity to formulate their own beliefs free from the dogma and dictates of an authoritarian institution.
That said, there are going to be some fabulous high-camp moments that I am just not going to miss. These include:

1. Viewing the body of the Blessed Pier Giorgio - we rarely get to see the fossilised remains of dead people in Australia, and I wouldn't miss this macabre spectacle for the world.

2. The live Stations of the Cross - high-camp, real-life drama in the tradition of Jesus Christ Superstar. And the guy playing Jesus is a fox!

3. The Religious Orders Fun-Fair in Hyde Park - that's right, just across from the Cathedral they're setting up a kind of garden fete to encourage kids to join religious orders. Will there be a Franciscan jumping castle? The Benedictine super-slide? Put the balls in St. Therese's mouth? The possibilities are endless, and the implications of a pilgrims' fair are way too Chaucerian for me to pass up. I'm secretly hoping they will be selling indulgences.

4. Mary Mackillop's Tomb as Disneyland - the good Josephite sisters are ramping up operations at their actually quite tasteful headquarters in North Sydney. They are installing porta-loos and hot dog stands and charging punters 10 bucks to get into the church and spend some quality time at Mother Mary's tomb. Or you can buy a $30 all-day ticket which includes a continental breakfast and a whirlwind tour through the bizarre museum out the back that no-one ever visits.

I'm sure that there are actually some good and worthwhile events happening too. I am aware, for example, that the wonderful people at the World Christian Meditation Community - genuine good guys - will be operating an alternative space all week at the Paddington Uniting Church, where people can go and meditate and spend some quiet, genuinely contemplative and spiritual time. But for the most part the whole WYD event is an exercise in bombast, chauvinism and tackiness, and on balance it has done enormous damage to the reputation of the Catholic Church in Australia.

4 comments:

Joe McKay said...

Dear Waterblog

Unfortunately there will be no Franciscan waterslides. However the franciscans will be down at Bondi beach talking about peace.

www.franciscans.org.au/wyd

Peace and Good

Walter said...

Wonderful. I'm sure the Franciscans will be among the genuine high points of the festival.

magikquilter said...

Hi Walter I was wondering what it is you actually hate ...is it the waste of taxpayer's money and the homophobia it engenders or is it the Roman Catholic dogma altogether you dislike so much?

I really enjoyed reading your blog after I saw the link come up and seem to remember you love the retreats at Arcadia is it? Are they a different branch of Catholicism? Am no theologian so do not know the ins and out of it all and certainly do not know much about monastic life.

St Francis of Assisi's prayer or plea is one of my favourite's and it is in sharp contrast to a lot of the present day churches. The last lines aren't for everyone but it is truly beautiful as is the Magnificat and the Beatitudes [saw you loved those]

Please feel free to delete the prayer as this is your blog ...just thought that as you love truly beautiful prayers I would share that one with you, it is quite meditative too.

Great to meet you Walter, hope to see you around the QVB some day...great photos by the way.
Kathleenxx

Lord, make me an instrument of your peace,
Where there is hatred, let me sow love;
where there is injury, pardon;
where there is doubt, faith;
where there is despair, hope;
where there is darkness, light;
where there is sadness, joy;

O Divine Master, grant that I may not so much seek to be consoled as to console;
to be understood as to understand;
to be loved as to love.

For it is in giving that we receive;
it is in pardoning that we are pardoned;
and it is in dying that we are born to eternal life.

Tim Holland said...

I often read your articles out loud in my best Alan Jones voice. I particularly enjoyed doing so with this one.

Related Posts with Thumbnails